For about a year following the 1960 merger of the Lackawanna with the Erie, Phoebe continued unchanged. In 1962, for a time, the train was combined with the New York—Chicago Erie-Lackawanna Limited. By August of 1963, the Phoebe Snow had disappeared completely from the Erie-Lackawanna's timetable. But by 1964 Phoebe was back as the no-longer-hyphenated railroad's standard bearer on a New York—Chicago routing via Hornell and Youngstown, Ohio, with through cars to Buffalo from Hornell.

See a full set (breakfast, lunch & dinner) of Erie-Lackawanna dining car menus at Don Shorock's Phoebe Snow page.

From the pages of the Official Guide, December 1964

Erie Lackawanna RR herald

The Phoebe Snow

Erie Lackawanna Railroad
November, 1964

New York - Hoboken via buses, subway, ferry
9 20A Dp Motor Coaches - Rockefeller Center Ar 7 10P
W. 42nd St at 8th Ave Ar 7 02P
W. 32nd St at 8th Ave Ar 7 00P
9 27A Dp W. 34th St at 8th Ave
9 49A Dp P.A.T.H. - 33rd St & 6th Ave Ar 6 58P
9 46A Dp P.A.T.H. - Cortlandt St. Ar 6 53P
9 45A Dp 0.0 Barclay St. Ferry (Mo-Fr, exc. Holidays) C Ar 6 57P
1 Train Number 2
Daily Miles Services Daily
10 15A Dp 1.0 Hoboken, NJ (ET) C R Ar 6 30P
R10 30A 8.8 Newark, NJ C R D 6 16P
R10 38A 11.6 Brick Church, NJ C D 6 04P
R10 51A 21.1 Summit, NJ C R D 5 50P
R11 20A 41.8 Dover, NJ C D 5 25P
11 52A 65.8 Blairstown, NJ C 4 55P
12 15P 82.6 E. Stroudsburg, PA C 4 34P
12 35P 95.6 Cresco, PA C 4 14P
12 50P 103.6 Pocono Summit, PA C 4 01P
1 30P Ar 134.1 Scranton, PA C R Dp 3 20P
1 40P Dp Ar 3 08P
2 45P Ar 192.7 Binghamton, NY C R Dp 2 05P
2 55P Dp Ar 1 50P
3 08P 201.3 Endicott, NY (Vestal) C 1 37P
3 27P 214.7 Owego, NY C 1 21P
3 49P 233.8 Waverly, PA C 1 01P
4 10P Ar 251.4 Elmira, NY C R Dp 12 40P
4 25P Dp Ar 12 25P
4 50P 268.8 Corning, NY 12 06P
5 35P Ar 309.9 Hornell, NY C Dp 11 15A
31 Connecting Train Number 32
6 00P Dp 309.9 Hornell, NY Ar 10 48A
D 6 50P 354.0 Warsaw, NY R 9 57A
8 00P Ar 403.5 Buffalo, NY (515 Babcock St.) Dp 8 45A
5 50P Dp 309.9 Hornell, NY C Ar 11 05A
6 25P 336.1 Wellsville, NY C 10 35A
7 20P 373.3 Olean, NY C 9 49A
7 45P Ar 391.2 Salamanca, NY C Dp 9 25A
7 55P Dp Ar 9 15A
8 40P 424.9 Jamestown, NY C 8 25A
9 18P 451.8 Corry, PA C 7 46A
10 02P Ar 493.5 Meadville, PA C Dp 6 57A
10 10P Dp Ar 6 50A
10 52P 519.7 Greenville, PA C 6 17A
11 20P 535.8 Sharon, PA C 5 51A
11 40P Ar 549.4 Youngstown, OH C Dp 5 25A
11 59P Dp Ar 5 07A
F12 11A 558.2 Niles, OH C
12 28A 563.3 Warren, OH C 4 44A
1 02A Ar 593.5 Kent, OH C Dp 4 02A
1 07A Dp Ar 3 55A
1 24A 603.6 Akron, OH C R 3 39A
2 21A 654.1 Ashland, OH C 2 30A
2 48A 670.8 Mansfield, OH C 2 07A
3 19A 686.2 Galion, OH C 1 45A
3 45A Ar 707.2 Marion, OH C Dp 1 20A
4 00A Dp Ar 1 05A
4 59A 759.1 Lima, OH C 11 54P
F 5 27A 786.4 Ohio City, OH C
5 48A 802.9 Decatur, IN C 11 06P
6 20A Ar 833.7 Huntington, IN (ET) C Dp 10 35P
6 30A Dp Ar 10 25P
F 6 13A 875.4 Rochester, IN (CT) C 8 40P
F 6 44A 906.5 North Judson, IN
F 7 18A 940.0 Crown Point, IN C F 7 30P
7 40A 955.7 Hammond, IN C 7 11P
8 00A 970.0 Englewood, IL (63rd St - Chicago) C X 6 44P
8 15A Ar 976.3 Chicago, IL (Dearborn Station) (CT) C R Dp 6 30P

Train 1 (Hoboken-Chicago): 42 stops, 23:00, 42.4 MPHTrain 2 (Chicago-Hoboken): 39 stops, 23:00, 42.4 mph

No. 1—The Phoebe Snow - Daily

Sleeping Cars—(Car No. 11) New York to Chicago—10 Roomettes, 6 Double BR
Seat Space (Car No. 11) New York to Meadville 

Observation Lounge—New York to Meadville 

Diner—New York to Chicago (In service from New York to 10:00 pm, and from 6:00 am to arrival Chicago) 

Coaches—New York to Chicago, New York to Buffalo (No. 31 from Hornell), Buffalo to Fort Wayne via N&W No. 5 

No. 2—The Phoebe Snow - Daily 

Sleeping Car—(Car No. 21) Chicago to New York—10 Roomettes, 6 Double BR
Seat Space (Car No. 21) Meadville to New York 

Diner—Chicago to New York (In service from Chicago to 10:00 pm, and from 6:00 am to arrival New York) 

Observation Lounge—Meadville to New York 

Coaches—Chicago to New York, Buffalo to New York (No. 32 to Hornell)


Phoebe continued on this routing and on very nearly this same schedule through July of 1966.  At some point  later in that year, Phoebe made her last run.